South Gloucestershire Council v DN [2022] EWCOP 35 (12 August 2022)
7th September 2022
Poonam Bhari instructed by Charlotte Melhuish of Stone King Solicitors LLP represented the School, which is a small charitable and independent special school, in this challenging, difficult and complex case.
The case concerned DN a 17 year old boy with co-morbid diagnosis of Autistic Spectrum Disorder, Severe Learning Difficulties and Tourette’s Syndrome who had been residing at the School under Section 20 of the Children Act 1989.
DN physically assaulted staff members at the school in March 2022 leading to staff requiring medical treatment and staff resignation. DN subsequently physically assaulted members of staff in May 2022 resulting in staff long-term sick leave and resignations.
The School gave the Local Authority six weeks’ notice to terminate the placement in accordance with its contract with the Local Authority. The Official Solicitor acting on behalf of DN issued proceedings. DN lacked capacity to make decisions as to his care and residence.
Following an initial hearing the School extended the notice twice, initially for a period of a further seven days to enable the Local Authority to find an alternative placement for DN.
The Local Authority, DN and his parents contended that DN should be permitted to live at a house at the School, but not under the care of the School itself, notwithstanding the notice to terminate the placement. The School was concerned about this proposal in light of its statutory obligations (including in relation to ‘Keeping Children Safe in Education 2021’), and potential breach of Trustees duties, and jeopardising and placing the School’s OFSTED registration at risk due to the dual use of an unregistered placement in a registered children’s home.
The Court decided that DN must return home as the court cannot ‘wave a magic wand’ and provide for a suitable placement for DN where none exists.
Read more about this case here:
Related Articles
-
3PB Barristers (3 Paper Buildings) is delighted to announce that family barrister Hannah Bush will officially be appointed as a District Judge from next Monday 18th November 2024. District Judge Bush will sit on the Midlands Circuit and be based at the Birmingham Combined Court Centre. Hannah was called to the Bar in 2007 and was appointed as a Deputy District Judge and a fee-paid First Tier Tribunal Judge in May 2020. Teaching advocacy part-time...
Continue reading -
3PB Barristers’ Family Law team has achieved 27 individual rankings (+5 compared with 2024) in this year’s Chambers and Partners edition published today. 23 of our family law barristers are ranked across 5 Circuits: in London, the Midlands, North Eastern, South Eastern and Western. While our team is once again rewarded with Band 1 rankings for both Family Children and Family Finance in the Midlands and retains its Band 2 ranking in Western, our family...
Continue reading -
3PB Barristers (3 Paper Buildings) breaks another record in the latest edition of Chambers and Partners with a total of 96 rankings (81 last year) achieved by 80 of its barristers. The national set is rewarded with accolades in 21 areas of law, in the London Bar as well as in the North Eastern, South Eastern, Western and Midlands Circuits and exceptional comments for its expertise and service delivery. Click here to view the full...
Continue reading -
The three pupils starting their twelve-month pupillages, pictured left to right from the top, are: former Fleet Air Arm Officer James Hume who is focused on commercial litigation and arbitration as well as property and construction law; former paralegal in Slaughter and May’s Disputes and Investigation team Emily Hayward is focusing on civil law disputes, particularly commercial, property and personal injury and Victoria Holland, a former human rights paralegal with law firm Hickman & Rose,...
Continue reading
