Nick Robinson’s client found not guilty of assault; highlighting the importance of the Section 28 Procedure
15th March 2022
The case centred on whether the defendant committed a serious sexual assault against his 5-year old niece. The defendant denied the allegation and contended that his niece was either mistaken or wrongly attributing to him the behaviour of another family member.
The case involved sensitive third party disclosure and an application pursuant to section 41 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003. The social services records indicated previous reports by the complainant to her parents and a social worker relating to similar sexual activity with someone other than the defendant and in analogous circumstances. Nick made an application to ask the complainant questions about this evidence, which the Judge granted.
The complainant was cross-examined at a hearing pursuant to section 28 Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999. Therefore, she was questioned over 7 months before the main trial and her evidence was video recorded. As a result of the complainant's answers to Nick’s questions the prosecution conducted a review of the case and the police made further enquiries. Ultimately, the prosecution offered no evidence. This case illustrates the practical advantages of the section 28 procedure.
An added layer of complexity in this case arose from the defendant's severe autism and learning disabilities. This necessitated the instruction of a psychiatrist, psychologist and an intermediary as well as consideration of the defendant’s fitness to plead and stand trial.
The trial was held at Oxford Crown Court before HHJ Maria Lamb. Nick was instructed by Kevin Bourne of Hurleys Solicitors.
Related Articles
-
3PB Barristers (3 Paper Buildings) breaks another record in the latest edition of Chambers and Partners with a total of 96 rankings (81 last year) achieved by 80 of its barristers. The national set is rewarded with accolades in 21 areas of law, in the London Bar as well as in the North Eastern, South Eastern, Western and Midlands Circuits and exceptional comments for its expertise and service delivery. Click here to view the full...
Continue reading -
3PB Barristers criminal barrister Berenice Mulvanny represented one of two Chichester community rangers who were charged with assault and false imprisonment of a 15 year old boy in Superdrug on 22nd March 2023. This case attracted considerable media attention after a short clip of the incident was published on the internet with allegations the incident was racially motivated. Miss Mulvanny's client detained the youth after being headbutted by the youth who was trying to shoplift....
Continue reading -
3PB Barristers congratulates its first-class Criminal and Regulatory Law team for another strong result in Chambers and Partners’ 2025 edition. Not only has the team retained its Band 1 ranking for Crime in the Western Circuit, with 10 of its practitioners ranked in this area of law, it has also added 2 new rankings for Health and Safety in Western, now totalling 3 ranked barristers. While our barristers are praised for their forensic analyses, strategic...
Continue reading -
3PB's crime barrister Thomas Acworth (pictured here) acted for JP, a 60-year-old man of previous good character, who was accused of serious sexual offences said to have taken place from the late 1970s to the mid 1980s. He was tried before HHJ Feest KC at Winchester Crown Court. The indictment included 22 incidents of what would now be charged as rape of a child under 13. The litigation involved considerable arguments over disclosure, which were...
Continue reading
