Bitcoin Security: Should Developers Be Held Liable?
2nd March 2023
3PB Barristers’ (3 Paper Buildings) specialist commercial and chancery barrister Aaron Mayers (pictured here) discusses a recent dispute that was heard in the Court of Appeal regarding whether Bitcoin network developers have a fiduciary duty towards Bitcoin owners.
The case in question involves Tulip Trading Limited, which lost $4bn in Bitcoin when the private keys to its wallet disappeared in a hacking incident in 2021. Tulip brought claims against a number of Bitcoin network developers based on the allegation that a fiduciary duty exists between them, and that this should extend to Bitcoin network developers implementing the necessary software patch to restore Tulip’s assets.
Aaron explores the issues raised in relation to service of the claim through the High Court – which ruled that Tulip’s claim had insufficient merits to be heard – and the subsequent appearance in the Court of Appeal, which upheld the appeal and ruled that there was merit for the issue to be tried.
Aaron offers commentary on what the forthcoming trial could mean for the future of Bitcoin, offering the view that were this trial to go favourably for the Claimant, it could open “the possibility for Bitcoin owners to pursue claims against developers if they fail to act in the owners' best interests”, which “could have a significant impact on the liability of developers”.
Click here to read Aaron’s full analysis
Aaron Mayers is an experienced commercial and chancery barrister with a particular focus on developing litigation strategy and providing commercially viable advice in complex and high-value commercial and trusts disputes.
To contact or instruct Aaron, please contact his clerks Patrick Robson, Patrick Steptoe, and David Fielder or call 0207 583 8055.
Related News
-
3PB are pleased to announce that barristers Alice Horn, Jack Felvus and Laurie-Elizabeth Ketley (pictured here, left to right) have successfully completed their twelve-month pupillages and become members of the 250-barrister, national chambers. Former Prince of Wales and David Karmel Scholar Alice Horn (call:2022) joins following a ten-year career in industry internationally. Alice is a much-in-demand barrister with significant experience in both County Court and High Court matters and specialises in commercial litigation, adjudication and...
Continue reading -
3PB's Chief Executive Simon Astill is one of the keynote speakers this coming Friday 15 November 2024 at Dubai's Hyatt Regency in the UAE. Speaking on "Cross-border commercial contracts: strategic approaches to dispute resolution clauses and international enforcement," Simon is one of four speakers at this legal and business conference organised by the Dubai Chapter of the ICAI (Institute of Chartered Accountants of India). He joins Syed Mujtaba Hussain, the founder and Managing Partner of...
Continue reading -
3PB Barristers (3 Paper Buildings), one of the UK's largest chambers, is celebrating this year again its rankings - totalling 167 - in the Legal 500 2025’s edition published today, a 15% increase on last year’s 145. The set is ranked in 23 areas of law, across 4 UK Circuits: London, South Eastern, Western and the Midlands. 3PB’s barristers are also ranked in the Middle East and Asia Pacific regions. The Legal 500 acknowledges 3PB...
Continue reading -
3PB (3 Paper Buildings) senior member of the commercial, costs and property & trusts team Cheryl Jones has been nominated for the Inspirational Women in Law Awards. Started in 2016 as a celebration with 5 finalists from across the legal profession leading the way in improving and equality and diversity, has grown into an annual celebration of countless men and women across several categories who are both excelling in their areas of practice and are...
Continue reading
